Tuesday, June 24, 2008

so many search, so little time

Activity 1


1. Based on this research topic, choose relevant keywords to search for relevant 3 resources.

2. What are the keywords that you would use?

Keywords: HSDPA, HSDPA development, advances in HSDPA


3. List the variations to your keywords.

Keyword
HSDPA

Keyword variations
HighSpeedDownlinkPacketAccess, mobile telecommunications


4. Write down the search phrases that include the keyword and variations as identified above.

High Speed Downlink Packet Access developments
Advances in mobile telecommunications
Wireless data transfer using HSDPA

5. Use the following search facilities to search for the 3 resources:
(Refer to Lecture notes 4 & 5)

· Search engine (use only one example)
· Meta search engine (use only one example)
· Subject directory (use only one example)

Within each category of search facility, there are many examples to select from. Identity the ones you like best and use them for your search.

6. Record your search process in the table below.


Type of Search facility
Keywords used
URL of the resource
Size of hits?

Search Engine

Example used :
http://www.google.com/
HSDPA, HSDPA development
www.digit-life.com/articles2/mobile/wimax.html
2,750,000

Meta Search Engine


Example used :
IxQuick
HSDPA, HSDPA development
www.freescale.com/ webapp/ sps/ site/ overview.jsp?nodeId=02XPgQ750882662622
6,239,536

Subject Directory

Example used :
Yahoo! Directory
HSDPA, HSDPA development
http://www.novatelwireless.com/
33

Comparison and Evaluation on search effectiveness

You must then evaluate and compare the effectiveness of each search facility. You may use criteria such as the differences and similarities in terms of search capabilities, result ranking, size of hits, etc. You are encouraged to use your own initiative to suggest other areas of discussion and comparison.

Compare the search results. Identify 2 characteristics that make all 3 search facilities similar or different from one another.

Search is done according to the keywords but results varies with type. I feel that search engines are the best choice for searching as they provide searches with the most relevance as compared to directory or metasearch.

Do you find any strength/weakness of each of them, in terms of search capability?

Directory search yields the lest relevant results and metasearch in my opinion gives too much choices for the user to properly choose one. A lot of time is needed to slowly browse through all the links found thus reducing efficiency.

Overall, which search facility best meet your searching needs? Why?

The search engine as it gives me the results according to relevance as well as number of views improving the quality of the search.

No comments: